Skip to content

Canada's Business and Tech Newsroom

  • Professional Subscription
  • Partnerships & Advertising
  • Licensing & Syndication
Log In Subscribe
Welcome,
  • My Account
  • Log Out
  • Business
  • Tech
  • National
  • The Big Read
  • Briefings
  • Commentary
Search
Log In Subscribe
Welcome,
  • My Account
  • Log Out
News

Winning Toronto-Quebec City high-speed rail bid was so low officials feared it was impossible, documents reveal

OTTAWA — The winning bid for Via Rail’s high-speed project was so low that government evaluators checked repeatedly whether it might be impossible, according to documents obtained by The Logic.

News

Winning Toronto-Quebec City high-speed rail bid was so low officials feared it was impossible, documents reveal

Feds triple-checked bid from group that includes AtkinsRéalis and Air Canada to make sure the massive project will get done

By David Reevely
A high-angle, head-on shot of a moving Via passenger train. There are four sets of tracks in the shot, and the train is on the right-most set.
The Cadence consortium will work with Via Rail to build and operate the high-speed rail line between Toronto and Quebec City. Photo: The Canadian Press/Christinne Muschi
Jul 29, 2025
A A
A Small A Medium A Large
Share

Gift

Share

OTTAWA — The winning bid for Via Rail’s high-speed project was so low that government evaluators checked repeatedly whether it might be impossible, according to documents obtained by The Logic.

In one of his last acts as prime minister, Justin Trudeau announced in February that the consortium called Cadence would take on Canada’s biggest infrastructure project ever. Cadence is to work with Via to plan, build and operate a new fast passenger rail line between Toronto and Quebec City. It’s to replace Via’s poky service on tracks mostly leased from CN, from which passenger trains are often shunted in favour of freight.

The group includes the Caisse de dépôt et placement du Québec, AtkinsRéalis (formerly SNC-Lavalin) and Air Canada, along with several companies affiliated with France’s national railway, SNCF. It was up against bid groups featuring Germany’s national rail company Deutsche Bahn and Spain’s Renfe.

Talking Points

  • A new high-speed rail line between Toronto and Quebec City is to be the biggest infrastructure project in Canadian history, with a price previously estimated at $60 billion, or more
  • When government evaluators looked at the terms of the bids from three heavy-hitting consortiums seeking to take the project on, they were so startled by how low one of them was that they triple-checked whether it could even be done
  • All the bids were strong, say documents obtained by The Logic, but the dollars and cents put the one from a group that includes CDPQ, AtkinsRéalis and Air Canada over the top

First conceived as “high-frequency rail,” or “HFR,” the initial idea was that reliable, frequent trains on dedicated tracks would be enough to revive passenger rail in the densely populated corridor between Ontario’s and Quebec’s provincial capitals. The government has since upgraded the plan to a European-style high-speed rail, promising trains that reach 300 km/h.

Alto, the Via subsidiary championing the project, has estimated the cost to be between $60 billion and $90 billion. The planning phase alone is to take six years and cost more than $4 billion.

The documents, released in response to an access-to-information request, are materials prepared last fall, summarizing the bid evaluations for the deputy minister at Transport Canada and the top procurement official at Public Services and Procurement Canada (PSPC), the department running the competition.

It gave codenames to the three bid groups—the winner was labelled “Sleeper Car,” and it beat out “Locomotive” and “Diner Car.”

“All three proposals were high quality and reflected extensive consideration of market, technical, operational and customer experience factors in developing a realistic, defensible and actionable Train Service Proposition,” the briefing materials said. “All bidders demonstrated extensive real-world experience and knowledge they could apply in developing diverse, customer-oriented strategies to provide a strong customer experience.”

Related Articles

Via hopes more private involvement will keep its rebuild in central Canada on the rails

By David Reevely
A photo of Martin Imbleau, head of Via Rail’s high-frequency rail project, wearing a grey suit, seated on the arm of a chair.

Via Rail’s Martin Imbleau on why the biggest Canadian building project in decades has no budget or timeline

By David Reevely

The winning bidder has “design experience with very relevant project experience, understanding of interdependencies between key functions from alignment identification and associated works, methodologies and understanding of the risks, accessibility, governance, and journey times,” the document went on.

All the scores except the best bid’s total were redacted from the documents the government released. It scored 107 out of a possible 120 points. But it stood out in one particular way.

“The preferred bidder’s total bid score is well above the other teams,” the document said. “This is due in large part to their very competitive commercial package.” Any details of that package are redacted.

PSPC’s spokesperson Nicole Allen confirmed to The Logic in an email what the documents don’t say directly: the “commercial package” covers “multiple financial aspects of the submission”—in other words, how much Cadence would charge.

The commercial proposal was worth up to 30 of the 120 points, and Cadence’s was so good it made the team at PSPC nervous, the briefing note said: “PSPC asked [subject-matter experts] and evaluators to confirm that the low commercial bid would not put the delivery of HFR at risk, and we were told it is not a concern.”

A few pages later, the document said the experts went over the numbers more than once to make extra sure: “In addition to the evaluators reviewing the bids individually, then in consensus, there were two series of reviews by the SME that confirmed the very competitive response did not put the project delivery at risk.”

The commercial proposal was worth up to 30 of 120 points in the bidding process. Cadence’s was so good it made government evaluators nervous.


Through spokesperson Martin Croteau, Cadence declined to say how it could so dramatically outbid the other groups, citing restrictions in its agreement with the government.

Matti Siemiatycki, director of the University of Toronto’s Infrastructure Institute, said in an interview that bid outcomes like this aren’t uncommon in major project procurements: accomplished teams of engineers and project managers typically come up with pretty similar technical proposals, but they win or lose on the dollars.

“You bid for the lowest technical score that will still keep you in the game, and then you aggressively drive down your financial bid,” he said. “The variation in the technical scores tends to not be all that wide, but the variation in the financial scores is really wide.”

In the best case, that just means the buyer gets a good deal.

“But what also can happen is that’s sort of an initial financial offering, and then the prices start going up, either before a contract is signed or as the project is going along,” Siemiatycki said. “Over time, it starts to look much more like what some of the higher bid prices were.”

The contents of the bids have not been released, and PSPC’s Allen said they won’t be: “To protect confidentiality, we cannot provide financial details of the bids,” she wrote. 

Without knowing those, Siemiatycki said, it’ll be impossible to track whether costs are creeping up.

Gift the full article

Alternatively, a cheaper bid can be reflected in workmanship. Siemiatycki pointed to problems with a new Toronto courthouse built through a public-private partnership, and a lawsuit over allegedly shoddy floors in a marquee hospital project.

“In practice, there’s all sorts of ways that risk, even though it’s transferred on paper, is not necessarily transferred in practice, and it can start to boomerang back to government in all sorts of ways,” he said.

#Air Canada #AtkinsRéalis #CDPQ #economy #high-frequency rail #high-speed rail #transportation #Via Rail

Sponsored Content

The road to risk-smart regulation

By Deborah Aarts

Why cybersecurity needs to match pace with AI

By Jessica Aftimus Rosa

How to shift your workforce from AI experimentation to adoption

By Jessica Aftimus Rosa
Paid promotional content

Loading...

Thanks for sharing!

You have shared 5 articles this month and reached the maximum amount of shares available.

Close
This account has reached its share limit.

If you would like to purchase a sharing license please contact The Logic support at [email protected].

Close
Want to share this article?

Upgrade to all-access now

Close
Gift the full article!

You have gifted 0 article(s) this month and have 5 remaining.

Copy link and gift
Copy Link
Email to a friend
Send Email
Gift on Social Media

Recipients will be able to read the full text of the article after submitting their email address. They will not have access to other articles or subscriber benefits.

A high-angle, head-on shot of a moving Via passenger train. There are four sets of tracks in the shot, and the train is on the right-most set.

Photo: The Canadian Press/Christinne Muschi

Most Popular This Week

A man with grey hair stands against a black background, wearing a black leather jacket and gesturing as he speaks.
News

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s resignation sends shockwaves through Canadian business and tech

By Catherine McIntyre
An aerial-style rendering of a massive data centre on a prairie landscape of farm fields and trees.
Exclusive

Another giant data centre is in the works for northern Alberta—right next to Meta’s

By Meghan Potkins
A close-up of computer equipment with the Tenstorrent logo on the casing.
Exclusive

Tenstorrent is lobbying Ottawa for data-centre funding and sovereign AI contracts

By Catherine McIntyre
Prime Minister Mark Carney, wearing a suit suit jacket, smiles and shakes hands with an Armed Forces member. Several rows of people stand behind them, wearing camouflage pants and red or white sweaters.
News

Canada’s Arctic defence push is overwhelming communities in the North

By David Reevely

In-depth, agenda-setting reporting

Great journalism delivered straight to your inbox.

Commentary

Carmichael: Macklem is stepping aside after a career of consummate public service

By Kevin Carmichael

Briefing

Canada’s largest oil producer to buy natural gas company Advantage Energy for $2.5B

By Meghan Potkins   |   Nov 16, 2026 | 2:40 PM ET

Telus pulls out of two Vancouver AI data centre projects with Westbank

By David Reevely   |   Nov 16, 2026 | 2:11 PM ET

Canaccord CEO to take firm private in $1.6B deal

By Chaimae Chouiekh   |   Nov 16, 2026 | 1:42 PM ET

Best business newsletter in Canada

Get up to speed in minutes with insights and analysis on the most important stories of the day, every weekday.

Exclusive events

See the bigger picture with reporters and industry experts in subscriber-exclusive events.

Membership in The Logic Council

Membership provides access to our popular Slack channel, participation in subscriber surveys and invitations to exclusive events with our journalists and special guests.

Recent Popular Stories

Exclusive

Another giant data centre is in the works for northern Alberta—right next to Meta’s

By Meghan Potkins   |   Nov 11, 2026
An aerial-style rendering of a massive data centre on a prairie landscape of farm fields and trees.
Exclusive

Tenstorrent is lobbying Ottawa for data-centre funding and sovereign AI contracts

By Catherine McIntyre   |   Nov 11, 2026
A close-up of computer equipment with the Tenstorrent logo on the casing.
News

Canada’s Arctic defence push is overwhelming communities in the North

By David Reevely   |   Nov 9, 2026
Prime Minister Mark Carney, wearing a suit suit jacket, smiles and shakes hands with an Armed Forces member. Several rows of people stand behind them, wearing camouflage pants and red or white sweaters.
News

AI tax firm Blue J’s valuation jumps past $1B with new investment

By Anita Balakrishnan   |   Nov 10, 2026
News

Big banks and developers urge Ottawa to halt private capital’s retreat from housing

By Chaimae Chouiekh   |   Nov 10, 2026
A new condo construction site is seen in downtown Toronto on Thursday, May 25, 2023.
News

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s resignation sends shockwaves through Canadian business and tech

By Catherine McIntyre   |   Nov 12, 2026
A man with grey hair stands against a black background, wearing a black leather jacket and gesturing as he speaks.

Canada's most influential executives and policymakers are reading The Logic

  • CPP Investments
  • Sun Life Financial
  • C100
  • Amazon
  • Telus
  • Mastercard
  • bdc
  • Shopify
  • Rogers
  • RBC
  • General Motors
  • MaRS
  • Government of Canada
  • Uber
  • Loblaw Companies Limited
logic-logo

Canada's Business and Tech Newsroom

100% human-crafted journalism

Newsroom

  • News Tips
  • AI Policy
  • Editorial Disclosures
  • Story Pitches

Company

  • About Us
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Statement
  • Corporate Information

Contact

  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • FAQs
  • Work at The Logic

© 2026 The Logic Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Trusted by leaders

Error

Account creation failed.

Please email us at [email protected].

Create Account

[wppb-register form_name=”cozmo-registration-form-for-modal”]

I do have an account
Login
or

[wppb-login]

I don’t have an account