Skip to content

Canada's Business and Tech Newsroom

  • Professional Subscription
  • Partnerships & Advertising
  • Licensing & Syndication
Log In Subscribe
Welcome,
  • My Account
  • Log Out
  • Business
  • Tech
  • National
  • The Big Read
  • Briefings
  • Commentary
Search
Log In Subscribe
Welcome,
  • My Account
  • Log Out
Commentary

Carmichael: Canadian ignorance about India is a strategic weakness

Listen Now
0:00
Commentary

Carmichael: Canadian ignorance about India is a strategic weakness

Businesses need to put in the work if they want to reap the rewards of a deal with an economy seven times the size of Canada’s

By Kevin Carmichael
Children play in the Jari Mari slum in Mumbai, India, as an airplane crosses low overhead before landing at Mumbai Airport in September 2026. Photo: NurPhoto via Getty Images/Saurabh Sirohiya
Oct 10, 2026
A A
A Small A Medium A Large
Share

Gift

Share

Listen Now
0:00

My colleague Joanna Smith got a lot out of India’s high commissioner when she talked to him in Ottawa last month. I can’t get one of Dinesh K. Patnaik’s comments out of my head. It says everything about how the world has changed since former prime ministers Stephen Harper and Manmohan Singh agreed to begin trade talks in 2010. 

The Indian government, said Patnaik, wants Canada to recognize the “mismatch in the size of the economies.” 

I hear a diplomat putting the other side of a negotiation in its proper place. There’s some hope that India’s trade agreement with the European Union could herald a similar pact with Canada. It might, but I think it would be a mistake to assume Canada will come away with equally favourable terms. We lack both the economic weight and the cachet to expect otherwise.

Related Articles

Canadian and U.S. flags wave beside Gordie Howe International Bridge under a clear blue sky.

Carmichael: How free trade with the U.S. made Canadian businesses lazy

By Kevin Carmichael
An image of two docked icebreakers covered in snow and ice.

Carmichael: What Finland can teach Canada about sleeping next to an elephant

By Kevin Carmichael

Status influences just about every human interaction. It’s easy to imagine that 16 years ago, Canadian negotiators started talks with India feeling like they had the upper hand. Their bosses were venturing out into the world with some swagger. The oilpatch was booming and Bay Street had survived the 2008-2009 financial crisis intact. Harper, who had been in power for nearly five years, decided it was time to make his debut at the World Economic Forum’s annual retreat at Davos, Switzerland. “My purpose was to get out the story of Canada’s successful economic management to an international audience,” he wrote in his book Right Here, Right Now.   

For a long time, Canada offset its relative lack of economic weight with the prestige of having emerged as one of the economic winners from the Second World War and being a member of all of the right clubs. That might have worked when India’s economy was only around three times larger than ours, as it was in 2010, when measured in terms of purchasing power parity. 

India’s economy is now almost seven times larger than ours. If it required Canada’s help two decades ago, it doesn’t now. Disembarking at Mumbai’s Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj airport after a half-day flight from any Canadian departure point is like travelling to the future. The chaos outside is a quick reminder that India has some work to do, but it is no longer a country that will be cowed by a mid-sized economy with an enviable level of GDP per capita. 

Canadians can be naive about our standing in the world. We were ruined by British preferential tariffs and privileged access to America. Financial and transportation links formed to facilitate those trade flows at the expense of creating channels to other places. We became incurious about the rest of the world. When I moved to Mumbai in September 2014, I was encouraged to find myself interviewing various Canadians within weeks of my arrival. Then I learned that everyone tries to get to Mumbai in October or November for official business because the weather is glorious. I don’t recall meeting many Canadians during the June to September monsoon, nor the summer months of March, April and May, when the heat and humidity make it difficult to be outside. 

A poll by the Angus Reid Institute last year found that almost 70 per cent of Canadians admitted to knowing little or nothing about India, even though South Asians represent the country’s largest racialized group. “That is a strategic weakness at a moment when India is becoming more consequential to Canadian interests,” Vina Nadjibulla, co-founder and CEO of the Centre for Strategic Statecraft, wrote in an essay earlier this year. 

I’ve learned that ignorance about India makes you susceptible to generalizations that can lead to disenchantment when they come up against reality. One heuristic that gets Canadians in trouble is the notion that because India is big and fast-growing, it must be full of opportunity for a country such as Canada. That depends on a Canadian entrepreneur’s willingness to visit India during monsoon and other inconvenient times of year. It’s a place that values relationships. The executives who travel there with International Trade Minister Maninder Sidhu this week shouldn’t expect to go home with a contract. Gary Comerford, the executive who led Sun Life’s expansion to India, boasts that he’s visited the country more than 90 times since the mid-1990s. 

Rapid economic growth only matters if you can supply the Indian market with what it wants. The Canadian Chamber of Commerce’s Business Data Lab on Monday unveiled a new web tool that makes real-time estimates for where Canadian merchandise exports have the most potential to grow. Andrew DiCapua, the lab’s principal economist, said he was surprised that slow-growing Europe came out ahead of Asia. That discovery tracks Export Development Canada research. EDC used a trade gravity model to estimate where Canadian exports underperform. For goods, India was only 12th. “It hasn’t always been a predictable market,” said Craig Johnston, chief economist at Farm Credit Canada. 

I called Johnston because of another trope. Canadian trade with India has come to be defined by bulk shipments of lentils and peas. Johnston said any trade agreement should create incentives for Canadian industry to turn those raw materials into food ingredients, which capture more value and make Canada less vulnerable to Indian politicians’ tendency to protect farmers from import competition. 

Gift the full article

An enlightened approach to India might also move beyond the short-term interest of Canadian pulse growers. EDC’s gravity model isn’t ecstatic about the potential of India for goods exports, but when it comes to services, only the U.S. ranks higher. 

That means Sun Life might have more to teach us about trade with India than Saskatchewan’s cash croppers. Surprised me too.   

Kevin Carmichael is The Logic’s economics columnist and editor-at-large. He has spent more than two decades covering economics, business and finance for outlets including Bloomberg News, The Globe and Mail and the Financial Post, where he also served as editor-in-chief. 

#commentary #economy

Sponsored Content

The road to risk-smart regulation

By Deborah Aarts

Why cybersecurity needs to match pace with AI

By Jessica Aftimus Rosa

How to shift your workforce from AI experimentation to adoption

By Jessica Aftimus Rosa
Paid promotional content

Loading...

Thanks for sharing!

You have shared 5 articles this month and reached the maximum amount of shares available.

Close
This account has reached its share limit.

If you would like to purchase a sharing license please contact The Logic support at [email protected].

Close
Want to share this article?

Upgrade to all-access now

Close
Gift the full article!

You have gifted 0 article(s) this month and have 5 remaining.

Copy link and gift
Copy Link
Email to a friend
Send Email
Gift on Social Media

Recipients will be able to read the full text of the article after submitting their email address. They will not have access to other articles or subscriber benefits.

Photo: NurPhoto via Getty Images/Saurabh Sirohiya

Most Popular This Week

A man uses a computer keyboard in Toronto in this Sunday, Oct. 9, 2023 photo illustration.
News

Scammers are infiltrating Bay Street with social engineering

By Anita Balakrishnan
An image of a man sitting in an armchair in a dimly-lit room. He is wearing glasses and a dark-blue suit and patterned tie. He is clasping his hands in front of him, while looking away from the camera with a serious facial expression.
Commentary

Carmichael: Macklem is stepping aside after a career of consummate public service

By Kevin Carmichael
An image of a man wearing dark clothing, standing on a stage and speaking. He is wearing a mic and gesturing. Behind him is a white and black background with text.
News

Securities regulators just gave a Wealthsimple-backed stablecoin a major leg up

By Claire Brownell
A man with grey hair stands against a black background, wearing a black leather jacket and gesturing as he speaks.
News

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s resignation sends shockwaves through Canadian business and tech

By Catherine McIntyre

In-depth, agenda-setting reporting

Great journalism delivered straight to your inbox.

Exterior picture of Tumbler Ridge Secondary School with out-of-focus police tape in foreground and police cars on the road next to the school.
News

OpenAI asks judge to throw out Tumbler Ridge shooting lawsuits and keep chat records sealed

By Catherine McIntyre

Briefing

Dominion Dynamics touts 12-company alliance behind its military drone plans

By David Reevely   |   Nov 20, 2026 | 6:00 AM ET

OSFI proposes looser capital rules to boost banking competition

By Chaimae Chouiekh   |   Nov 19, 2026 | 3:26 PM ET

Video game giant Ubisoft cuts 166 staff at Quebec studios

By Brendan Sinclair   |   Nov 19, 2026 | 2:56 PM ET

Best business newsletter in Canada

Get up to speed in minutes with insights and analysis on the most important stories of the day, every weekday.

Exclusive events

See the bigger picture with reporters and industry experts in subscriber-exclusive events.

Membership in The Logic Council

Membership provides access to our popular Slack channel, participation in subscriber surveys and invitations to exclusive events with our journalists and special guests.

Recent Popular Stories

Exclusive

Another giant data centre is in the works for northern Alberta—right next to Meta’s

By Meghan Potkins   |   Nov 11, 2026
An aerial-style rendering of a massive data centre on a prairie landscape of farm fields and trees.
News

Koho says it’s going after fraudsters who used a tech glitch to falsely credit accounts

By Claire Brownell   |   Nov 17, 2026
An image of a man with dark hair and a beard, wearing a blue-grey suit jacket and a white shirt. He is standing with his hands in his pockets while leaning against a glass railing.
Exclusive

Alberta is bringing in rules to block frivolous data-centre proposals

By Meghan Potkins   |   Nov 14, 2026
A head-on shot of Nate Glubish seated and speaking into a microphone he's holding in his right hand. He's wearing a blue patterned blazer.
Exclusive

Tenstorrent is lobbying Ottawa for data-centre funding and sovereign AI contracts

By Catherine McIntyre   |   Nov 11, 2026
A close-up of computer equipment with the Tenstorrent logo on the casing.
News

Securities regulators just gave a Wealthsimple-backed stablecoin a major leg up

By Claire Brownell   |   Nov 16, 2026
An image of a man wearing dark clothing, standing on a stage and speaking. He is wearing a mic and gesturing. Behind him is a white and black background with text.
News

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s resignation sends shockwaves through Canadian business and tech

By Catherine McIntyre   |   Nov 12, 2026
A man with grey hair stands against a black background, wearing a black leather jacket and gesturing as he speaks.

Canada's most influential executives and policymakers are reading The Logic

  • CPP Investments
  • Sun Life Financial
  • C100
  • Amazon
  • Telus
  • Mastercard
  • bdc
  • Shopify
  • Rogers
  • RBC
  • General Motors
  • MaRS
  • Government of Canada
  • Uber
  • Loblaw Companies Limited
logic-logo

Canada's Business and Tech Newsroom

100% human-crafted journalism

Newsroom

  • News Tips
  • AI Policy
  • Editorial Disclosures
  • Story Pitches

Company

  • About Us
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Statement
  • Corporate Information

Contact

  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • FAQs
  • Work at The Logic

© 2026 The Logic Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Trusted by leaders

Error

Account creation failed.

Please email us at [email protected].

Create Account

[wppb-register form_name=”cozmo-registration-form-for-modal”]

I do have an account
Login
or

[wppb-login]

I don’t have an account