Skip to content

Canada's Business and Tech Newsroom

  • Professional Subscription
  • Partnerships & Advertising
  • Licensing & Syndication
Log In Subscribe
Welcome,
  • My Account
  • Log Out
  • Business
  • Tech
  • National
  • The Big Read
  • Briefings
  • Commentary
Search
Log In Subscribe
Welcome,
  • My Account
  • Log Out
Commentary

Carmichael: Canada has problems, but the deficit isn’t one

It’s been a tough start to the budget season for fiscal hawks. 

First, British Columbia Finance Minister Katrine Conroy presented a pre-election financial plan that forecasts a deficit wider than the shortfall the province ran during the COVID-19 recession, and the province’s largest debt burden as percentage of gross domestic product in almost forty years. 

Commentary

Carmichael: Canada has problems, but the deficit isn’t one

Our politicians need to make choices, but there’s no ’90s-style debt crisis on the horizon

By Kevin Carmichael
Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland in Ottawa on Feb. 27. Photo: The Canadian Press/Adrian Wyld
Feb 28, 2024
A A
A Small A Medium A Large
Share

Gift

Share

It’s been a tough start to the budget season for fiscal hawks. 

First, British Columbia Finance Minister Katrine Conroy presented a pre-election financial plan that forecasts a deficit wider than the shortfall the province ran during the COVID-19 recession, and the province’s largest debt burden as percentage of gross domestic product in almost forty years. 

Then, New Democratic Party Leader Jagmeet Singh announced that he and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau had agreed on legislation that would provide universal coverage of contraception and diabetes medication at a cost of about $1 billion a year. 

“Single-payer pharmacare is a risk our country can’t afford right now,” Kathy Megyery, a senior vice-president at the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, said in a statement. 

The desire of the party that keeps Trudeau in power for more social spending proved more persuasive than the various fiscally conservative economists, small-government think tanks and business lobbyists who insist Canada is on the road to perdition. “We believe in investing in the health of Canadians,” Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland said at a press conference Tuesday. “We laid out a clear set of fiscal guideposts in the fall economic statement. We will meet those guideposts.”  

Related Articles

Carmichael: The end of the gen-X economic consensus

By Kevin Carmichael

Carmichael: Poilievre makes the business of governing sound easy

By Kevin Carmichael

Freeland’s fall fiscal update pledged to keep the deficit from growing in the immediate term, keep the debt-to-GDP ratio on a downward track and get the deficit-to-GDP ratio below one per cent by 2027. That’s no one’s definition of austerity, but it’s better than most of Canada’s peers, which should be enough to keep the bond vigilantes at bay. 

Given all the disruption that’s happening, Freeland’s approach is a reasonable mix of prudence and long-term bets. Canada can afford a pharmacare program if that’s how it chooses to use scarce resources. And though resources are more scarce than they were in the late 1990s and during the commodities boom of the early 2000s, the federal government and the provinces can borrow at relatively reasonable rates. 

The average yield on five- to 10-year federal debt was 3.35 per cent in January, according to Bank of Canada data. That’s a significant increase from 1.76 per cent, the average of the past 10 years. But it’s nothing like the double-digit rates Canada paid in the early 1990s, when the country was on the verge of becoming a fiscal basketcase. Today, the government of Canada is among a dwindling number of sovereigns with a AAA credit rating, yet some who favour austerity frame their arguments as though Canada were on the verge of a debt crisis. 

“Deficits impose a disproportionate tax burden on future generations,” the Fraser Institute’s Jake Fuss and Grady Munro wrote in The Globe and Mail earlier this month. 

Not if that spending generates economic growth, or helps build a social safety net that offsets inequality. Ambitious finance ministers have been ignoring the advice of economists and thought leaders since Alexander Hamilton read Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations, used those ideas to help him demolish the notion that the U.S. economy should be based on agriculture, and then dismissed Smith’s theory of free trade in favour of import tariffs and subsidies that he felt were necessary if fledgling American factories were to have a chance against established competitors in Europe. 

Hamilton liked free trade in theory, but “experience,” he wrote in the “Report on the Subject of Manufactures,” showed that “men are often so much governed by what they are accustomed to see and practice, that the simplest and most obvious improvements, in the [most] ordinary occupations, are adopted with hesitation, reluctance and by slow gradations.” In other words, getting out of the way of the invisible hand might well improve the welfare of individuals, but you can’t trust it to achieve larger national objectives. Those “may therefore require the incitement and patronage of government,” according to Hamilton. 

Context matters. Canada isn’t a developing country in the early stages of building an industrial base, able to count on high rates of future growth to pay off whatever debt it takes on today. But we’ve entered a moment where disruption is everywhere. An aging population, the mental health crisis and the threat of further pandemics demand an overhaul of our approach to health, welfare and retirement. Climate change and artificial intelligence will transform the global economy. Geopolitical rivalry will demand a greater financial commitment to defence. All this while inequality feeds political polarization that is making democracies harder to govern.

Is this really a moment when governments should prioritize balancing their budgets because, in theory, that’s optimal policy? Experience suggests the stakes are too high. 

Fuss and Munro would balance the federal budget by cutting “corporate welfare.” Good advice in the 1990s, when a new free-trade agreement with the United States and Mexico and the prospect of freer trade with China offered Canadian companies lots of opportunity. But that’s not the world we’re in today. It’s more like the period between 1921, when the Alberta government backed research at the University of Alberta into extracting bitumen from the province’s oilsands, and the late 1970s and 1980s, when government funding allowed a handful of private companies to turn those oilsands into a going concern. 

The tens of billions of dollars in subsidies that Ottawa and the governments of Ontario and Quebec have deployed over the past couple of years could be wasteful, but the spending represents the same kind of bet we made on the oilsands. You can have a debate over the environmental costs of developing Alberta’s oil industry, but it’s impossible to argue those early investments were a waste of money. 

Gift the full article

Big spenders such as Freeland and the governments of British Columbia, Ontario and Quebec should certainly be held to account, but balancing the budget just for the sake of balancing the budget is no longer the right standard.  

Kevin Carmichael is The Logic’s economics columnist and editor-at-large. He has spent more than two decades covering economics, business and finance for outlets including Bloomberg News, The Globe and Mail and the Financial Post, where he also served as editor-in-chief. 

#B.C. #Chrystia Freeland #commentary #economy #pharmacare

Sponsored Content

The road to risk-smart regulation

By Deborah Aarts

Why cybersecurity needs to match pace with AI

By Jessica Aftimus Rosa

How to shift your workforce from AI experimentation to adoption

By Jessica Aftimus Rosa
Paid promotional content

Loading...

Thanks for sharing!

You have shared 5 articles this month and reached the maximum amount of shares available.

Close
This account has reached its share limit.

If you would like to purchase a sharing license please contact The Logic support at [email protected].

Close
Want to share this article?

Upgrade to all-access now

Close
Gift the full article!

You have gifted 0 article(s) this month and have 5 remaining.

Copy link and gift
Copy Link
Email to a friend
Send Email
Gift on Social Media

Recipients will be able to read the full text of the article after submitting their email address. They will not have access to other articles or subscriber benefits.

Photo: The Canadian Press/Adrian Wyld

Most Popular This Week

A man uses a computer keyboard in Toronto in this Sunday, Oct. 9, 2023 photo illustration.
News

Scammers are infiltrating Bay Street with social engineering

By Anita Balakrishnan
An image of a man sitting in an armchair in a dimly-lit room. He is wearing glasses and a dark-blue suit and patterned tie. He is clasping his hands in front of him, while looking away from the camera with a serious facial expression.
Commentary

Carmichael: Macklem is stepping aside after a career of consummate public service

By Kevin Carmichael
An image of a man wearing dark clothing, standing on a stage and speaking. He is wearing a mic and gesturing. Behind him is a white and black background with text.
News

Securities regulators just gave a Wealthsimple-backed stablecoin a major leg up

By Claire Brownell
A man with grey hair stands against a black background, wearing a black leather jacket and gesturing as he speaks.
News

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s resignation sends shockwaves through Canadian business and tech

By Catherine McIntyre

In-depth, agenda-setting reporting

Great journalism delivered straight to your inbox.

An image of Prime Minister Mark Carney walking across a red carpet. He is wearing a dark suit and tie. Behind him is a large blue banner. In front of him are many cameras and people behind them.
Commentary

Carmichael: Mark Carney’s leadership style is creating key-man risk

By Kevin Carmichael

Briefing

Canada joins NATO Innovation Fund for venture investments with $100M pledge

By David Reevely   |   Nov 21, 2026

2,000 workers set to return to revamped Ford factory

By Anita Balakrishnan   |   Nov 20, 2026

Oil tanker shipments from Trans Mountain’s marine terminal in B.C. rise sharply in October

By Meghan Potkins   |   Nov 20, 2026

Best business newsletter in Canada

Get up to speed in minutes with insights and analysis on the most important stories of the day, every weekday.

Exclusive events

See the bigger picture with reporters and industry experts in subscriber-exclusive events.

Membership in The Logic Council

Membership provides access to our popular Slack channel, participation in subscriber surveys and invitations to exclusive events with our journalists and special guests.

Recent Popular Stories

Exclusive

Another giant data centre is in the works for northern Alberta—right next to Meta’s

By Meghan Potkins   |   Nov 11, 2026
An aerial-style rendering of a massive data centre on a prairie landscape of farm fields and trees.
News

Koho says it’s going after fraudsters who used a tech glitch to falsely credit accounts

By Claire Brownell   |   Nov 17, 2026
An image of a man with dark hair and a beard, wearing a blue-grey suit jacket and a white shirt. He is standing with his hands in his pockets while leaning against a glass railing.
Exclusive

Alberta is bringing in rules to block frivolous data-centre proposals

By Meghan Potkins   |   Nov 14, 2026
A head-on shot of Nate Glubish seated and speaking into a microphone he's holding in his right hand. He's wearing a blue patterned blazer.
Exclusive

Tenstorrent is lobbying Ottawa for data-centre funding and sovereign AI contracts

By Catherine McIntyre   |   Nov 11, 2026
A close-up of computer equipment with the Tenstorrent logo on the casing.
News

Securities regulators just gave a Wealthsimple-backed stablecoin a major leg up

By Claire Brownell   |   Nov 16, 2026
An image of a man wearing dark clothing, standing on a stage and speaking. He is wearing a mic and gesturing. Behind him is a white and black background with text.
News

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s resignation sends shockwaves through Canadian business and tech

By Catherine McIntyre   |   Nov 12, 2026
A man with grey hair stands against a black background, wearing a black leather jacket and gesturing as he speaks.

Canada's most influential executives and policymakers are reading The Logic

  • CPP Investments
  • Sun Life Financial
  • C100
  • Amazon
  • Telus
  • Mastercard
  • bdc
  • Shopify
  • Rogers
  • RBC
  • General Motors
  • MaRS
  • Government of Canada
  • Uber
  • Loblaw Companies Limited
logic-logo

Canada's Business and Tech Newsroom

100% human-crafted journalism

Newsroom

  • News Tips
  • AI Policy
  • Editorial Disclosures
  • Story Pitches

Company

  • About Us
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Statement
  • Corporate Information

Contact

  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • FAQs
  • Work at The Logic

© 2026 The Logic Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Trusted by leaders

Error

Account creation failed.

Please email us at [email protected].

Create Account

[wppb-register form_name=”cozmo-registration-form-for-modal”]

I do have an account
Login
or

[wppb-login]

I don’t have an account