Toronto fintech Koho has gone to court to recover about $5.2 million, saying users exploited a technical glitch in its bill payment system to fraudulently credit more than 1,000 accounts over the course of two days.
On Nov. 9, a Toronto judge granted Koho’s request to freeze funds held in 987 accounts at 23 institutions—including all Big Six banks and prominent fintechs Wealthsimple and Shakepay—that received the improperly credited money. The judge also ordered those institutions to disclose the names, addresses and transaction records of the people behind the affected accounts.
Talking Points
- Toronto fintech Koho said in court filings that users exploited a technical glitch that effectively credited their accounts with money out of thin air if they paid a bill and immediately cancelled it; the scam generated $5.2 million over the course of two days before the company patched the bug
- A Toronto judge has frozen the funds, which users transferred to almost 1,000 accounts at 23 financial institutions, including all Big Six banks and prominent fintechs Wealthsimple and Shakepay
Koho users e-Transferred the funds generated by the glitch between Oct. 30 and the afternoon of Nov. 1, when the fintech blocked all bill payments to stop the outflow.
Sean Dunphy, the Ontario Superior Court justice who granted the order, said in his decision that the exploit was “clearly a dishonest one.” The incident appears to be either an organized attack or a group of people taking advantage of the glitch all at once after someone disclosed it, possibly through “a viral post on some social media platform,” Dunphy said.
In an emailed statement, Koho CEO Daniel Eberhard said “the incident has been contained, and Koho’s systems remain fully secure and operational.” He said the perpetrators didn’t compromise the fintech’s internal systems and that the affected funds belong to Koho. “As artificial intelligence has increased the complexity and speed of cyberattacks, particularly over the past few weeks, this incident reinforces Koho’s commitment to keeping pace with evolving threats,” he said.
Koho, one of Canada’s highest-profile fintechs, raised $130 million at a $1.33-billion valuation in June from investors including Abu Dhabi sovereign wealth fund Mubadala. At the time, Eberhard said it was growing quickly, with revenue in the mid-$200 million range, and that it is “getting very close” to obtaining a banking licence, a milestone it’s been working on since 2021.
According to an affidavit filed in support of the firm’s court motion, the users involved in the exploit would start a bill payment in a Koho account and cancel it right away. In what it calls a flaw in “timing logic,” Koho credited the accounts with the cancelled payment amount, even though no money had ever left.
Effectively, the accounts got free money out of thin air, according to the filing. Small transfers started leaving the affected accounts around 7 p.m. EST on Oct. 30, with volume picking up the following morning. A Koho investigator noticed one instance of the problem at about 11:30 a.m. on Nov. 1, a Sunday.
Koho said it blocked all bill payments just after 1:30 p.m. that day, ending the incident. In all, some $5.2 million left through more than 1,600 e-Transfers of up to $5,000 each, not including purchases made directly from the Koho accounts that the fintech said it’s still investigating.
As of Nov. 7, institutions that received the funds have confirmed that about $234,000 is recoverable, according to the filing. Some institutions—including TD and BMO, which collectively received about $1.73 million—have not responded other than to acknowledge the message, Koho said.
BMO and RBC declined to comment. National Bank spokesperson Alexandre Guay said the lender “has and will continue to comply with all applicable court orders.” Wealthsimple spokesperson Rachael Factor said Koho is best placed to comment on the matter. TD, CIBC, Scotiabank and Shakepay did not respond to requests for comment by deadline.
Koho said it doesn’t know who was behind the attack, or what role the account holders played. In an anticipatory move, though, the fintech is seeking at least $5.2 million in damages from the alleged fraudsters—identified only as “John Doe, Jane Doe and ABC Corporations” in the lawsuit—plus $1 million in punitive damages and costs.
Koho suffered a similar incident in 2020, in which users exploited a glitch that allowed money to be claimed if a sender cancelled, so long as a receiver accepted within milliseconds. That incident involved more than 1,000 transactions totalling more than $1 million. The statement provided by Eberhard did not address a question asking how an incident so similar in nature could happen again.
The judge granted the freezing orders through a legal maneuver known as a Mareva injunction, which is designed to prevent a defendant from hiding or disposing of assets before they can be seized in a future judgment. Courts made use of it to freeze bitcoin donations collected to support the convoy protests against COVID-19 restrictions that snarled Ottawa in 2022.
The freezing order expires 10 days after it’s put in effect unless Koho applies for a renewal. The next hearing is scheduled for Nov. 19.